back to www.audiodesignguide.com |
To get more information contact me at: webmaster@audiodesignguide.com |
THIS IS NOT A COMMON PUSH-PULL!
- very
low feedback only 16dB
- low distortion near to 0.3 - 0.4%
- good damping factor near to transistor amp.
- no electrolytic capacitors
started on March 10 st , 2012
INTRODUCTION
After many years
designing single ended amplifiers I have decided to start a series of
test
about the Push Pull amplifiers.
These amplifiers are considered at a lower level than single ended but if you
want a power enough to drive ESL loudspeakers and low distortion systems like
Audiotechnology,
Dynaudio,
Scanspeak,
Morel and
Seas there is no other choice.
The main problem of Push-pull amplifier is the not perfect distortion decay with
the
cancellation of even harmonics but if
we keep the distortion level very low this consequence can be ignored and
the sound will not be affected.
Another
characteristic of many Push-pull amplifier is the high global feedback used to
get a good damping factor because to increase the output power often are used
output transformers with low turn ratio.
Here I am using a 10Kohm UL central
tap instead of 4 - 5Kohm normally used
for the KT88 in commercial amplifier.
As my others amplifiers to preserve the sound quality I have used the minimum number of
components on the signal path so only one inter stage capacitor is present.
Here I would like to create a Push-pull taking only the benefits of this design
and
minimizing the bad effects.
This amplifier, like the my other designs,
can be connected directly to
a CD Player or to a DAC without using a pre-amp.
The very good result got with the PP2010 and
availability of a pair of old 10Kohm Tecnotrafo (Italy) push-pull transformers
have forward me to create this new amplifier.
The low distortion of this project like in the PP2010 has been
obtain using a perfect phase inverter.
I know many DIY does not like
the printed circuit board
and the hybrid stage with fet
of PP2010 so I have created a new driver
stage with the same performances but using only vacuum tubes.
This new driver stage can be used without changes in the
PP2010 to get 50W.
Using only a pair of KT88 I have got 25W in triode connection and 35-40W using the ultra linear
configuration.
This power could be considered low for a pair of KT88 but I want
low feedback, low distortion and good damping factor.
To get the best sonic result there are no electrolytic
capacitors on the signal path and in the anodic power supply.
I have used this amplifier to drive
the my Monitor
3 and a pair of
Audiostatic ESL ES240, in both cases the result is very very good better
than previous PP2010.
UPDATE March 2013
I have inserted a 0.1uF
Auricap
to bypass to 2.2uF Solen to increase the sonic performances and the result is
very good.
This bypass work from 17Hz frequency because ft = 1 / (2 * 3.14 * R * C) = 1 /
(2 * 3.14 * 0.1E-6 * (180000/2)) = 17.
In the first schematic published there was no resistors on cathode but this has
been inserted to check the bias current.
Before insert KT88 check the bias voltage on grid setting the trimmer for the
max negative voltage.
UPDATE
December
2022
The heat generated by the 82K resistors destroyed the solen
capacitors so has been replaed with Jantzen Superior Z-Cap 0.68uF without
bypass.
Leave the pin long about 3-4cm and far from the 82Kohm resistances
(see last photos).
TUBES
To create a push
pull amplifier
is possible to use triode and pentode but obviously to test many configurations
like the ultra linear we need a pentode. There are many pentode good for audio amplifiers but the most common in the current production are the EL34, 6550 and the KT88 so follows a compare table with the main characteristics and price. In this amplifier you can use only KT88 and KT90.
The output plate characteristics have been measured with the Sofia computer-controlled curve-tracer by Audiomatica and I have added the lines to calculate the internal/plate resistance. |
To get the best
result use Genalex - Gold Lion KT88 matched quad tubes available in the shop
Audiokit.it,
thetubestore.com or
pmcomponents.co.uk. After extensive research and engineering, New Sensor Corp. has reissued the famed Genalex Gold Lion KT88. This tube has been recreated down to the finest detail with gold plated grid wire, carbonized screen grids, and a tri-alloy clad plate structure for exceptional performance and sound quality. As input tube I
suggest to use the
old 12AX7 Jan Philips or the
Sovtek
12AX7LPS the to get the best sonic result. About the PCL82
use Philips, Siemens or Mullard and if you change the filament is
possible use ECL82. |
In the datasheet is mention this limit:
tube model used | max cathode to heater voltage (max Vkf) | circuit cathode voltage (Vk) | heater voltage (Vf) | Vk - Vf |
ECC83 / 12AX7 | 180v | 0v | 0V | 0V |
PCL82 Triode | 200v | 150v | 150v | 0v |
PCL82 Pentode | 250v | 350v | 150v | 200v |
KT88 | 150v | 0V | 0V | 79V |
ECC83 socket, bottom view | KT88 socket, bottom view
|
PCL82 socket, bottom
view
|
TRANSFORMERS
I have used a
pair of old 10Kohm Tecnotrafo (Italy) push-pull transformers with UL.
In triode connection the KT88 with a load of 10Kohm anode to anode give an
output impedance of only 3ohm so with 10dB of feedback we have a good
damping factor near to a solid state amplifier.
The power supply transformer has been
created on my specification with an extreme low flux.
The primary has been calculated for 260V instead of 220V to keep the flux at
14000 gauss.
V prim | gauss | prim | gauss | prim | |||||
220 | 17000 | 260 | 14000 | 260 | |||||
V sec | A sec | VA | 17000/14000 | V sec | A sec | VA | V sec | A sec | VA |
410 | 0.4 | 164 | 1.18 | 483.8 | 0.4 | 193.52 | 480 | 0.4 | 192 |
410 | 0.4 | 164 | 1.18 | 483.8 | 0.4 | 193.52 | 480 | 0.4 | 192 |
130 | 0.2 | 26 | 1.18 | 153.4 | 0.2 | 30.68 | 150 | 0.2 | 30 |
6.6 | 5 | 33 | 1.18 | 7.788 | 5 | 38.94 | 8 | 5 | 40 |
6.6 | 5 | 33 | 1.18 | 7.788 | 5 | 38.94 | 8 | 5 | 40 |
6.6 | 2 | 13.2 | 1.18 | 7.788 | 2 | 15.576 | 8 | 2 | 16 |
17 | 2 | 34 | 1.18 | 20.06 | 2 | 40.12 | 20 | 2 | 40 |
total | 467.2 | total | 551.296 | total | 550 |
DRIVER
This driver stage give these performance:
Complete schematic
All the amplifier in Triode connection
KT88 distortion and frequency at 25W with 10dB of feedback Vin=0.69Vrms
All the amplifier in ULtralinear connection
KT88 distortion at 30W with 10dB feedback and Vin=0.69Vrms
All the amplifier in Triode connection
KT88 distortion and frequency at 25W with 16dB of feedback Vin=1Vrms
KT88 distortion and frequency at 35W with 16dB of feedback Vin=1.2Vrms
For the chassie the my choice is the HiFi-2000 mod. Slim 04/350 4U
1NSL04350B with 10mm frontal panel + 2 x Vented cover
3SL0103350ASOLATO + Inner Pierced Base 1BASE0105MAX got at Audiokit webshop
+ 2 custom pieces of 3mm aluminium.
Vandal Resistant Push Button
Switches RS Stock No. 174-6381 Manufacturer Apem Manufacturers Part No. AV021003C900 The panel cut out is 22mm, the same of noval socket, so this is the ideal choice for the 10mm front panel |